Reviews of the Best Broiler Pans of 2020

Finding the best broiler pan is no easy task. With the large number of imitations and cheap products that have flooded the market, it is important to do the right research before you make this purchase. A good broiler pan will have both durability and quality, allowing for years of outstanding cooking and flavor retention. The following list of broiler pans will offer the best combination of both quality and quantity for the aspiring (or professional) chef. The main qualities that are taken into consideration for a broiler pan include price, build, size, quality, and durability. Broiling is a great method to enhance your cooking, so it’s important to get the right pan for the job.

Broiler Pans: Our Top Picks

[wp-compear id=”4598″]

Professional Broiler Pans Reviews

Granite Ware Roaster/Broiler 2 Piece Set (19.2 x 12.2)

Granite Ware Roaster

Features We Love

  • Porcelain-coated carbon steel
  • Doubles as a roasting pan
  • Unique material mix promotes conductivity
  • Dishwasher safe
[su_box title=”Pros” box_color=”#137815″]
  • Suitable for commercial cooking
  • Even heat distribution improves cooking
  • Suitable for baking
[su_box title=”Cons” box_color=”#891212″]
  • More expensive than smaller pans
  • Too big for some kitchens
Editor's Review - Click to Expand/Collapse

The broiler pan that has been most well-received by the majority of cooks and chefs has been the Granite Ware roaster/broiler Set 2 piece set. This set has some special features that dedicated cooks really appreciate. It is made of a sturdy carbon and steel blend which gives it the most robust look and feel of any broiler pan on this list. It also weighs in at 3 lbs., meaning that is one of the sturdiest broiler pans on the market. This also provides a durability that means it will be suitable for repeated commercial use.

This pan has the ability to roast as well, which is a feature that many cooks appreciate. The carbon and steel blend allow for a more even heat distribution which leads to better cooking results. The increased heat conductivity also leads to an ability to more quickly cool down once out of the oven. Overall, this is a great piece that is very versatile and able to perform multiple kitchen functions. If you want a serious broiler pan, then look no further.

Range Kleen Porcelain Coated Broiler Pan (16 x 12.5)

Range Kleen Broiler Pans

Features We Love

  • 3 lbs. sturdy build
  • Perfect for large meat cuts
  • Porcelain-coated black steel
  • Safe up to 1025℉
[su_box title=”Pros” box_color=”#137815″]
  • Size, quality, and durability
  • Great for family or commercial kitchens
  • Easy cleanup
[su_box title=”Cons” box_color=”#891212″]
  • More expensive than smaller pans
  • Too big for some kitchens
Editor's Review - Click to Expand/Collapse

If you are interested in the Range Kleen brand but want a bigger size, then this pan is the perfect choice. The dimensions are 16” by 12.5”, allowing for all of the benefits of the Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan with an increased size capacity. The material is an effective blend of steel with porcelain coating, which makes for a product that is light but also has non-stick capabilities. The pan is suitable for temperatures up to 1,025 degrees Fahrenheit, making it one of the few broiler pans on the market that can be used in commercial kitchens. The size also means that portions will not be an issue. Though it is durable enough for a professional chef, this is also the perfect addition to a home kitchen. It is also designed to be dishwasher safe for easy cleanup, a feature that comes in handy if you broil often.

The pan weighs in at a sturdy 3 lbs. This is a piece of cookware that will last for years and even decades. It gives a nice even cook throughout and is a solid addition to any kitchen. If you broil often, then you should prefer a high quality construction. Consider looking into the Range Kleen brand, they are committed to getting broiling right.

Whirlpool Porcelain Broiler Pan (16.5 x 12.5)

Whirlpool Porcelain Broiler Pan

Features We Love

  • 3 lbs. sturdy build
  • Easy drain slits for liquid
  • Porcelain coating for easy cleanup
  • Dishwasher safe
[su_box title=”Pros” box_color=”#137815″]
  • Best all-purpose
  • Splatter guard design
  • Porcelain non-stick won’t fade
[su_box title=”Cons” box_color=”#891212″]
  • Porcelain not as durable as steel
Editor's Review - Click to Expand/Collapse

This selection is perhaps the best all-purpose broiler pan that is available. It is a black porcelain pan that has been custom designed to prevent splatter and drain the juices in an effective manner. Though this is just one of the many benefits of a porcelain build. As far as durability is concerned, this pan will be more viable than a glass one. However, it still seems that steel will have the more longevity than other choices.

One of the advantages of this pan include specified ridges and splatter protections that will keep your oven clean. This is part of an overall design that is popular with cooks who like to keep their kitchen tidy. The pan is also sturdy and robust, weighing in at 3 pounds. The build is reminiscent of how cookware used to be made, both solid and functional. The grid size is 16.5 inches by 12.5 inches, leading to increased portion size if desired. Another advantage is that this pan is dishwasher safe and the porcelain surface makes for easier cleanup in the dishwasher.

Range Kleen 2 Piece Set (12.75 x 8.5)

Range Kleen 2 Piece Set

Features We Love

  • Steel grill and base
  • Suitable for outdoors
  • Doubles as a baking dish
  • Safe up to 1025℉
[su_box title=”Pros” box_color=”#137815″]
  • Good value
  • Steel infused for durability
  • Light
[su_box title=”Cons” box_color=”#891212″]
  • Smaller portion sizes
Editor's Review - Click to Expand/Collapse

This is another compact broiler pan that offers interesting features that are unique to its brand. The material is a porcelain and steel mix which gives it a longevity advantage over the other pans. Once again, the size of the pan comes down to personal preference and preferred use. This smaller broiler pan is great for entertaining small groups of guests and friends but can have difficulty producing large serving sizes. That being said, it is perfect for a compact kitchen and even a commercial kitchen when space is tight. It is also the second lightest pan on the list at 1 lb.

Many people love this pan for its design and ability to fit into tight spaces. They find that the combination of porcelain and steel to give it the extra heat conductivity needed to make the broil outstanding. It is not surprising that this is one of the most highly rated broiler pans on the market. If you are looking for a high quality pan at a great price, then consider the Range Kleen 2 Piece Set (12.75 x 8.5).

Wilton Non-Stick Broiler Pan (11 x 7)

Wilton Non-Stick Broiler Pan

Features We Love

  • Glossy black finish
  • Compact
  • Easy release for simple cleanup
  • 5-year warranty
[su_box title=”Pros” box_color=”#137815″]
  • Best value
  • Good for small kitchens
  • Best suited for small gathering
[su_box title=”Cons” box_color=”#891212″]
  • Glass not as durable as steel
  • Smaller portion sizes
Editor's Review - Click to Expand/Collapse

The Wilton Non-stick Broiler Pan Set, 11 x 7-Inch is the value pick of broiler pans. Pricewise, it is the best you can do for both value and quality. However, it comes with some drawbacks that the other pans don’t have. The primary problem being that the size is not suitable for everyone’s needs. The main advantage that this pan offers is the price point, which is the lowest among highly-reviewed broiler pans. It is also unique because it uses glass as the primary building material – differentiating it from other broiler pans. Glass can offer a nice aesthetic, but it also functions as a good heat conductor to complement broiling capabilities. Glass can also provide an advantage in terms of visual appeal and cleanup, as compared to steel. However, this may decrease durability over the long run, depending on use frequency.

This is a sturdy little pan that will work perfectly in many different situations. It is important to know the specifics of your own situation to determine whether or not this is the best fit for you and your kitchen. However, it is hard to beat this price point for smaller kitchens. For this reason, the Wilton Non-stick Broiler Pan (11 x 7) wins the pick for best value.

Broiler Pan Comparison Table

CooktopRatingDimensions (in inches)Price
 Granite Ware Roaster/Broiler 2 Piece Set (19.2 x 12.2)4.811 x 7Price not available
Range Kleen Porcelain Coated Broiler Pan (16 x 12.5)5.016.5 x 12.5$25.95
Whirlpool Porcelain Broiler Pan (16.5 x 12.5)4.812.75 x 8.5$24.24
Range Kleen 2 Piece Set (12.75 x 8.5)4.916 x 12.5$20.49
Wilton Non-Stick Broiler Pan (11 x 7)519.2 x 12.2$31.32

Broiler Pan Buying Guide


Price considerations for broiler pans are less important than other purchases that you might make for your kitchen. However, it is still important to get a pan that will fulfill your needs and last for many years. Getting a high-quality broiler pan doesn’t have to break the budget. There are many options that will cost you less than $25. Features are the most important consideration for this particular piece of cookware, unless you are a on a shoestring budget. When it comes to a broiler pan budget, less can be more.


Size is an important consideration for a broiler pan. It is important that the pan works in conjunction with the size of your kitchen, but also your cooking habits. A smaller pan will work for a tighter kitchen but won’t be able to cook large portions. It is important note the considerations for space and whether you primarily cook for yourself or others.

As well, some people prefer lighter weight broiling pans while others like the look and feel of the more dense old-fashioned designs. Your habits in the kitchen are your own, so this is going to ultimately come down to personal preference. Considering how you want to use your broiler pan in the future will provide a good direction as to which pan is right for you.


The main materials for broiler pans typically include porcelain, steel, and glass. Different brands also can blend these materials to give a specific look and feel to the pan. Material can affect heat distribution, weight, and longevity of the product. Steel tends to be a better conductor of heat but is typically harder to clean than porcelain. There are also products that incorporate a porcelain coating on top of steel to get the benefits of both heat conductivity and the look and cleanup of a traditional broiler pan.

Again, this comes down to what design and weight you prefer for your own pan. All the materials combine to make the pan function for you, so it is important to consider the look and feel of the pan you want.


The main features to consider for a broiling pan include durability and design. Some broiler pans feature unique splatter guards and other protection mechanisms that make for easier cleanup. Many cooks also like pans that can serve the duel purposes of both roasting and broiling. Make sure that the pan you want contains features that make cleanup easier. This will save time and hassle in the long run.

Durability is also a key issue for pans, so make sure to buy a high quality pan that will last. Your broiling pan should make your time in the kitchen more enjoyable and functional, not more complicated. The pans listed above do an outstanding job of meeting every criteria that is important to the average consumer.


Overall, choosing the perfect broiler pan is not always easy. It ultimately comes down to the habits of the chef or cook in question. Some on this list are more suitable for personal use and small gatherings, while other can stand the pressures of heavy-duty commercial wear and tear.

Broiling is a great cooking option to have, as it gives the cook the ability to brown and sear meat without the addition of fats and oils. This can lead to healthier cooking choices and delicious flavor pairings. Broiling is one of the key skills that a chef or cook must master in order to refine their craft. The pans on this list are an outstanding addition to any kitchen, but personal preference will always be the most important factor when it comes to selecting a broiler pan.

About Colin Matthews

Cookwared Reviews is a website run by two roommates, Colin Matthews and Samantha Brooks. 

While we have tested many of the products hands-on, some of the reviews featured on our website are based on our online research, reading reviews from other customers, watching videos on youtube, and comparison specs from the manufacturers. 

You might be interested in:

You might also like

Matfer Bourgeat Frying Pan

If you search for carbon steel frying pan on Mazon then you will see that MatferBourgeat Frying Pan is the best carbon steel pan with